Butter, more commonly known as Scaredy, is known for being cowardly like Flaky. Butter has white fur with a yellow tint to it. Whereas Cuddles has truly yellow fur, Butter's fur is a more buttery color, hence the name Butter.
- Butter may be the first cat of the Happy Tree Friends.
- Butter likes coloring and drawing pictures of butterflies.
- Butter is a vegetarian, but he'll eat fish on occasion.
- Despite the fact that he's a cat, Butter loves his pet mouse, Scampers.
- He's Flaky's best friend.
- When scared, Butter may kill who/whatever is threatening him with his claws.
- Butter collects stuffed animals.