After improperly injecting novacaine into Handy's mouth, Aqua tries to drill out the tooth. When Aqua is drilling, the drill's battery goes dead, much to her disappointment. However, Aqua managed to get another battery, she attempted several times of place the battery in the drill. Unfortunately, she only succeeds in drilling a hole in the back of Handy's throat. Next, Aqua tries the old fashioned method of tying one end of a string around Handy's tooth, and the other end to a doorknob. Aqua rings a doorbell, and Buckethead answers the door, causing Handy's jaw to get ripped from his head. Handy's rotten tooth is one of only a few teeth that aren't torn out due to this attempt. Before the episode ends, however, the tooth falls out on its own.
- There were three endings planned for this episode (including the one that was used) that were drawn up on the storyboard. The first alternative ending involved Aqua getting into Handy's mouth and hitting his teeth out of his mouth using a golf club, whereupon the decayed tooth lands in a golf hole. The second alternative ending involved Aqua using a car jack in Handy's mouth, tearing off the top part of Handy's head.